ALMENA, Wis. — Cheese is a passion for Eric Ludy and Gene Graf. They combined their decades-long appreciation for all things cheese when they launched Cheese Brothers near the Barron County town of Almena.
Their shared cheese story goes back to 1919, when Ludy’s great-grandparents immigrated to Barron County from Switzerland. An accomplished cheesemaker, Ludy’s grandfather established the Twin Town Cheese Factory. His father added Lake Country Dairy to become one of the largest producers of hard Italian cheeses, until the businesses were sold.
“I grew up in the cheese business, working at Lake Country,” said fourth-generation Wisconsin cheese purveyor Eric Ludy. “It was always my job that I had growing up, but I never thought I would end up in what was our family’s business.”
Enter Graf, a long-time family friend, who ran the packaging department at Lake Country Dairy, where they offered cut-and-wrap services to other cheese processors. When the plant was sold, the new management discontinued the service. Graf recognized the value it had and launched his own business, Barron County Cheese.
Ludy returned to the area and reconnected with Graf, learning that he was selling random cuts of cheese at area festivals with success.
“He hadn’t branded it or done anything to elevate it in any way,” Ludy said. “I had the creative background, so we created this brand. That was the formation of Cheese Brothers, birthed in those random white cheeses; but it became so much more.”
In its infancy, Cheese Brothers relied on Ludy traveling around the country for nearly five years, hawking cheese from a refrigerated van, visiting more than 40 cities each year. With the coronavirus pandemic, Ludy’s travels ground to a halt.
“We had a website that was doing a little bit of business, but when the pandemic grounded us from events, we had to focus entirely on the website,” Ludy said. “I honestly thought we’d go out of business; I didn’t think we could sell the volume of cheese we needed to online.”
After a couple of Facebook advertisements, Ludy and Graf learned differently.
“People were stuck home, getting groceries shipped to their houses, feeling a little insecure about food,” Ludy said. “All of a sudden we were an overnight success online, and we’ve been growing ever since. We’re the biggest cheese e-commerce company in the country at this point, and everything happens right here, in our shop in Barron County.”
The product marketed by Cheese Brothers comes from a variety of Wisconsin processors.
“We take this great cheese and package it up to make it giftable and fun,” Ludy said. “That’s my job, to make these products beautiful and to tell a story with them. My focus the last couple of years has been to create a gift experience — basically like an edible greeting card.”
More than 60% of Cheese Brothers sales take place in November and December, so Ludy looks to holiday marketing.
“We have a 12 Days of Christmas advent calendar that is one of our biggest sellers,” Ludy said. “We try to focus on the unboxing experience in creating our gift boxes, building from the high-quality cheese. If there’s a jar of jam in the box, I don’t want it to be something that you could have gone to the grocery store and bought.”
To create the desired aesthetic, Ludy seeks out small, local vendors.
“The point is giving somebody a taste of something they can’t find elsewhere,” Ludy said. “We don’t just stay in Wisconsin to source our cheese; everything else we offer is from Wisconsin, too.”
Cheese Brothers evolved from its earliest days of Ludy’s mobile cheese marketing expeditions to the vast world of e-commerce, shipping cheese to all 50 states. The next phase of the business is to establish themselves in more retail sectors, Ludy said.
“That’s been a huge growth piece for us,” he said. “In the last three years we went from zero retailers carrying our product to more than 3,000 retail outlets across the country. We cut out the intermediary by shipping directly to the stores.”
That retail growth has been a result of Cheese Brothers taking on two new partners, Sal DiStasio and Paul Brzezienski, the co-founder of the national retail brand, Red apple Cheese.
Regardless of who is on the receiving end, Ludy said he makes an effort to make each package one that represents Cheese Brothers in a positive manner.
“We dress our retail packages up just like we would a direct-to-consumer box,” Ludy said. “We package them well and make them look good. Some people might cut corners with wholesale shipments, but we take the opposite approach. We try to make it a nice visual experience for them, and for every person that handles the package between points A and B. That’s a chance we have to make that lasting imprint.”
The same idea plays into their customer service philosophy.
“We have three full-time people on customer service,” Ludy said. “They’ll spend all day on the phones, chatting with our customers. It’s important to us that when someone calls Cheese Brothers, someone here in Almena is going to answer the phone; they’ll hear that Wisconsin accent. Even if they chat online, it’s a real person right here in our office, not an AI chatbot. Those are corners you can’t cut.”
Ludy focuses his advertising efforts on digital marketing.
“We use ads on platforms like Google, Facebook and TikTok,” Ludy said. “It attaches to the algorithm, so if you show an interest in cheese, you’ll start seeing our ads everywhere.”
Cheese Brothers ships more than 100,000 boxes of cheese each year, equating to millions of pounds of cheese placed in the hands of consumers as unique gift experiences.
Cheese Brothers employs a year-round staff of five or six people, which mushrooms to as many as 50 or 60 throughout the busy holiday season.
“We treat our team members like family,” Ludy said. “We have built a good reputation around here, we pay above market rate, and we make it a fun place to work.”
Ludy and Graf are believers in fostering the communities that allow them to flourish.
“We believe in giving back; a portion of our profits go back to food shelves in our rural communities,” Ludy said. “It’s not just about dollars and cents; it’s about developing communities in rural America.”
Cheese Brothers has outgrown its Almena location, recently breaking ground for a new headquarters, fulfillment center and retail space in Turtle Lake, allowing them to take cheese gifting to another level.
“We love cheese,” Ludy said. “We want our customers to be excited to receive our packages in the mail, for it to be fun and an adventure to enjoy.”
Share with others
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here