People Moving Product

Melrose’s sweet spot

Knoll, Windsor open bakery, coffee shop

Posted

MELROSE, Wis. — Following the coronavirus pandemic, Sheri Knoll and Brandy Windsor were looking for a new challenge. Knoll was an avid home baker who sold goods at vendor events. Windsor was an in-home daycare provider and operated a storefront focused on protein shakes and natural, healthy energy teas. When an opportunity to combine their efforts at one location presented itself, they established Cookies & Cream Cafe in the heart of Melrose.

Windsor said she wanted to broaden her offering with coffee and other items.

“I kept talking to Sheri and telling her we should start our own café,” Windsor said. “She was so busy with a home bakery, I kept saying we needed to collaborate on something.”

An opportunity presented itself when the owners of a building on the main drag through town were looking for new renters and reached out to Windsor.

“They brought it to us, and we thought it was meant to be,” Windsor said. “Sheri could do the baked goods. I would do coffee and also have the nutrition side that had gathered a following at my previous storefront.”

Cookies & Cream Cafe, established in 2024, offers homemade baked goods and breakfast sandwiches, home-cooked lunches, Cedar Crest Ice Cream, handcrafted coffee and lotus drinks.

Knoll and Windsor use 60 pounds of butter, 32-40 pounds of cream cheese, 12 pounds of sour cream and 32-40 gallons of milk per month in their recipes and have a freezer full of ice cream at the cafe. They work with Max Hart from The Milkhouse Market to procure their milk from Weber’s Farm Store in Marshfield.

Dairy tradition extends beyond the menu for Knoll and Windsor, as the industry has deep roots in Jackson County and within their own families.

“My husband was a farmer,” Knoll said. “His family has farmed for generations, and his brother runs the dairy now. My husband appreciates that we use all the products we do and support family farms as much as we can. Farming is a hard job, so if we can do anything to help them, we think that’s very important.”

Knoll had made a name for herself locally as she was selling her baked goods at vendor events every weekend. The combination of the bakery products and Windsor’s following from her nutrition club, blended with the addition of coffee, made for a great recipe.

“The coffee side helps solidify us in the community,” Knoll said. “If not for us, people are going to Black River Falls, Sparta, West Salem, wherever, just for coffee. Here, we can provide them with that same experience.”

Behind the counter at Cookies & Cream Cafe is a wide array of flavors and syrups for coffee and tea. Homemade products find their way into the rotation as well.

“We don’t want to be in a little box,” Knoll said. “We like making the fun exotic drinks and, depending on the time of year, we make our own products that we can feature. We make pumpkin sauce, (and) we’ve made banana sauce (and) cheesecake cold foam; we like to make as many original products as we can.”

Windsor has cited that some patrons were pleasantly surprised by the wide variety of flavors and products available.

“When they come in, new people are expecting a little cup of coffee, and that’s it,” Windsor said. “They’ll see our selection and our products, and after they have a sip, they’ll say it’s better than some of the big chains.”

Cookies & Cream Cafe has become a part of the daily routines for people within their community, and Knoll and Windsor use social media to communicate and provide new ideas and specials with their followers.

“I’ll sometimes post a drink of the day,” Windsor said. “Customers come in specifically for that, especially those who have had our products before. This showcases the other products we can create.”

Along with being a daily staple for their community, Knoll and Windsor provide a service to help celebrate special events for friends and neighbors with customized orders. 

“Those are so meaningful to me,” Knoll said. “They’re entrusting me to add to their day. That makes me feel like I’m part of their event.”

Knoll’s foundation in baking is built on the time spent in the kitchen with her grandmother. She was the person who taught Knoll the ins and outs of baking and never skimped on adding butter or dairy to a recipe.

“We used to bake together, just the two of us, so it always makes me feel close to her,” Knoll said. “I wasn’t good at science as a kid, but she showed me how to combine baking soda, baking powder and flour — ingredients that don’t taste good on their own — and make something amazing that people can share with the people in their lives.”

Photo Caption Photo Caption Photo Caption Photo Caption

Share with others

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here

© Copyright 2024 Star Publications. All rights reserved. This material may not be broadcast, published, redistributed, or rewritten, in any way without consent.